In recent discussions, questions have arisen about whether Muslims condemn the events of October 7th, particularly the actions of Hamas. This inquiry often demands a straightforward condemnation without considering the broader historical and political context. A comprehensive Muslim response addresses these concerns by emphasizing the need for a balanced perspective.

Historical events that led to the current situation in Gaza:

• The Balfour Declaration and the Sykes-Picot Agreement.
• The displacement of 1.5 million people during the Nakba.
• Massacres committed by Israel, such as Deir Yasein in 1947.
• The ongoing detention of Palestinians without trial.
• The carpet bombings by Israel over the past 25 years.

Historical Context

The call for condemnation is often used to control the narrative, sidelining the historical injustices that have led to the current situation. The origins of the conflict can be traced back to the Balfour Declaration and the Sykes-Picot Agreement, where colonial powers arbitrarily divided the Middle East, disregarding the rights and identities of the local populations. These actions set the stage for the ongoing conflict, including the mass displacement of Palestinians during the Nakba.

Ongoing Injustices

Muslims condemn not only the recent violence but also the continuous injustices that have been perpetrated over decades. This includes the displacement of 1.5 million people during the first and second Nakba, the massacres such as Deir Yasein in 1947, and the current situation where thousands of Palestinians are held without trial in Israeli prisons. Furthermore, the carpet bombings and other acts of violence against Palestinians have persisted for over 25 years.

Media and Political Manipulation

There is also condemnation of the misinformation and propaganda that have shaped global perceptions of the conflict. False narratives, such as the fabricated claims of mass rapes on October 7th, have been used to justify further violence against Palestinians. These lies, perpetuated by major media outlets and political leaders, have fueled outrage and led to significant loss of life.

Changing the Narrative

The events in Gaza have exposed the hypocrisy of those who claim to champion human rights and democracy. The struggle of the Palestinian people has revealed the false moral superiority claimed by Western civilization. Despite the immense suffering, the people of Gaza have highlighted the injustice they face and garnered unprecedented global support for their cause.

Conclusion

Muslims call for a more nuanced understanding of the conflict, condemning not only isolated events but the broader context of occupation and oppression. By raising their voices and challenging biased narratives, they seek to achieve a more just and balanced discourse. The moral victory is already apparent, with growing global recognition of the Palestinian struggle for justice and freedom.